hiwatt

A Two-Input Hiwatt Mod

January 2012


During the late 70s, the final evolution of the Hylight Hiwatt preamp was produced. These amps are easily distinguished by the fact they have two input jacks (vs. the four of the earlier models).

two-input

Now, I *really* hate to second-guess Dave Reeves, but the distortion on some of these units when the input volume is turned to maximum sounds really spitty and unpleasant to my ears, particularly on the Normal channel. I did some research when I had one of these models in the shop for some work and found what was causing this effect.

The problem is called blocking distortion, and is caused when a vacuum tube stage is heavily overdriven. In the stock two-input amps, the output of the first stages go to the input volume controls, and from there directly to the input grid of stage two. When the input volume is at maximum, the coupling cap from stage one is pretty much directly connected to the input grids of stage two.

Note: This description and mod applies only to "normal" turret board two-input amps. The PCB two-input amps are likely candidates as well, but the images below won't match, of course. The later "OL" and "OVERDRIVE" amps produced by Biacrown do not need this mod, as they sort of already have it.

Technical Decription of the Problem

There is a good (but output-stage-centric) description of this problem on Randall Aiken's pages, but the problem paraphrased in preamp-centric form is this:

  • Preamp stages are almost always biased in class A, i.e., they conduct current for the entire waveform and the output signal is a (larger) close replica of the input signal. To do this, the stage is typically self-biased via a cathode resistor. This arrangement keeps the grid negative with respect to the cathode during normal operation. At idle, the grid is at zero volts, and the cathode is at 1.5 to 2 volts.
  • The R-C coupling normally used between stages tends to zero-balance the input waveform, i.e., the waveform is centered top-to-bottom around the normal idle bias level, and goes above and below zero, but with a mean level of zero.
  • The grid of a tube normally presents a very high impedance load to the driving source when it is biased in this manner. When the tube grid bias voltage nears zero, or goes positive with respect to the cathode, its input impedance drops drastically, and it starts drawing current from the source. It behaves similarly to a forward biased diode at that point.
  • The forward biased diode clamps the tops of the grid waveform to a relatively fixed point. Since the previous stage is R-C coupled to the grid, the tops are fixed at the clamp point and the entire waveform then shifts downward as signal level is increased, pushing the stage heavily into class B, with a resultant increase in distortion.
  • Because the time constant of the R-C coupling is large enough in this case, a transient distortion known as blocking occurs. This happens when the transient signal quickly pushes the clamped grid waveform down far into the cutoff region, and there is a finite time that is required for the grid waveform to recover and float back up to the correct bias point once the transient signal is removed. The input stage is still "centering" the signal, but the new center is much lower than the original, and mean level goes negative (as much as -14 volts in my tests). Until the bias comes back to the correct point, the second stage is effectively cut off for a major portion of the signal (effective class C operation). This results in an un-musical choppy, "fizzy" sounding distortion.

Solutions

During my investigations, I noticed that I could completely cut off the second stage for close to a second by just smacking muted guitar strings, when using the Normal channel!

The way to reduce this problem is to (1) reduce the size of the coupling cap, (2) reduce the shunt grid resistance, or (3) add a large series resistor in front of the grid, which limits the amount of "forward biased diode" current that can flow. (Note that the Bright channel has a much smaller coupling cap, and therefore the problem is not as bad on that channel.)

Changing the coupling caps would certainly change the sound of the amp, so I wanted to avoid that approach. The volume controls are already a low-ish 470k, and I didn't want to have to change them out anyway. Therefore, I decided to try the series grid resistor. I tried a number of values, but the problem persisted slightly even using resistors as high as high as 470k or 1M. I finally settled on the 1M value, because that gave the best reduction of blocking.

I used 2 watt metal film resistors for minimum noise, but any type of resistors will work fine in this position.

Adding a large series resistor will darken the tone a bit. I found that a little clockwise tweak to the Presence control brought things back to normal. You may want to try both values (470k vs. 1M). Another option you can try is adding 470p in parallel with the Bright channel series resistor (the one connected to V2 pin 7) to keep it as Bright as possible. This cap was standard on the 4-input models.

WARNING: I'm sure you realize this already. but modifying a vintage amp is a crime in some circles, and may reduce its resale value!


Here's an audio demonstration of this sound, before and after. Note that the master volume setting doesn't really matter as far as this effect is concerned. Note also, the effect is much more pronounced on the Normal channel.


Note: See also the alternate modification listed below.


The Modification (First Experiment)

(1) Remove the lug on the one V2 socket mounting screw, and replace it with a two-terminal tag strip (or a three-terminal strip if one lug is grounded, as is the case here).

tags

(2) Unsolder the two coax cables from V2 pins 2 and 7, and connect them, one to to each lug.

move coax

(3) Connect a resistor from each lug to its respective V2 pin. Bend the leads neatly in honor of the Hiwatt build heritage. :)
Solder each connection, and check it carefully.

add resistors

Thanks to JR for the use of his amp!


An Alternate Modification

Another (and perhaps better) way to accomplish this is to simply duplicate the original 4-input mixer circuit. Unfortunately, I don't have pictures for the last two steps of this version.

Steps (1) and (2) are the same as above.

(3) Unsolder and remove the jumper wire connecting V2 pins 1 and 6. There should now be nothing connected to V2 pins 1 and 2.

(4) Connect a 470k resistor from each lug to V2 pin 7. Bend the leads neatly in honor of the Hiwatt build heritage. :)
Solder each connection, and check it carefully.


Hiwatt Tech Page
 
Main Hiwatt Page